Calcium
Supplements
The
demand for calcium supplements is reflected by retail sales data. In 1993, calcium
supplements accounted for 6.7% of total supplement sales or $245 million a year
in the U.S.. Between 1994 and 1999, sales for calcium supplements increased 60%.
Reasons why individuals take calcium supplements are varied and include: concerns
about the adequacy of the calcium content of their diets; perceived or actual
milk protein allergy/lactose intolerance; and a desire to provide insurance against
calcium deficiency or to treat or prevent disease.
Calcium
is found in many foods and adequate calcium intake is important because
the human body cannot produce calcium. Even after reaching full skeletal growth,
adequate calcium intake is important because the body loses calcium every day
through shedding skin, nails, hair, and sweat as well as through urine and feces.
This lost calcium must be replaced daily through the diet. When the diet does
not contain enough calcium to perform these activities, calcium is taken from
the bones, the storage area for calcium.
The
National Academy of Sciences and the National Osteoporosis Foundation recommend
daily calcium intakes of 1000-1200 mg/day for adult men
and women. According to experts, food is the best source of calcium; however,
most Americans do not have enough calcium in their diets.
Fortunately,
calcium-fortified foods and calcium supplements can fill the gap, ensuring that
the daily calcium requirement is met. The amount needed
from a supplement depends on how much calcium is consumed from food sources.
According to a recent review of
calcium preparations, there are at least a dozen common calcium preparations and
hundreds of different formulations available. Calcium carbonate is the most common
preparation; some others include tricalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate, bone
meal, calcium citrate-malate, oyster shell, calcium lactate, and calcium gluconate.
These calcium preparations differ in a variety of ways. Calcium carbonate has
the highest concentration of calcium by weight (40%), whereas calcium citrate
has 21% calcium and calcium phosphate has 8% calcium by weight.
Although
calcium carbonate has the highest concentration of calcium by weight, this form
of calcium is relatively insoluble, especially at a neutral pH. In contrast, calcium
citrate, although containing about half as much calcium by weight, is a more soluble
form of calcium. Because calcium citrate does not require gastric acid for absorption,
it is a better choice for patients with achlorhydria (i.e., limited gastric acid
production).
In addition
to the amount (dosage) of calcium in various supplements, the solubility and absorption
of calcium must be considered. Prior to absorption, calcium preparations
must dissociate into elemental calcium. The more soluble a calcium supplement
product is in vitro (i.e., measured by the ability to dissolve in 6 ounces of
vinegar within 30 minutes), the more soluble the calcium preparation is in the
body.
While dosage and solubility
can influence the bioavailability of calcium from calcium supplements, the timing
of intake and meal conditions also are important. Calcium from supplements appears
to be more efficiently absorbed when consumed in divided doses, each containing
less than 200 mg of elemental calcium. The NIH Consensus Conference recommends
consuming calcium supplements between meals to increase calcium bioavailabilty.
The long-term safety of consuming
large doses of single nutrients including calcium is of concern. Although calcium
intakes up to 2,000 mg/day appear to be safe for most individuals, potential adverse
effects can occur as a result of chronic high intakes or intakes of specific calcium
preparations. Potential adverse effects include gastrointestinal problems such
as constipation. Certain preparations of calcium (e.g., bone meal, dolomite) may
contain contaminants such as lead, aluminum, arsenic, mercury, and cadmium. Significant
amounts were identified in calcium carbonate supplements labeled oyster shell
or natural source. Chronic intake of these supplements may pose an unnecessary
risk. Most commercial calcium preparations are tested for heavy metal contamination.
High intakes of calcium supplements
may interfere with the absorption of other nutrients such as iron and zinc. Intake
of calcium supplements also may interfere with the absorption of concurrently
consumed medications, and vice versa. Other potential adverse effects of chronic
intakes of high doses of calcium include milk-alkali syndrome (ectopic calcium
deposition), hypervitaminosis D (i.e., in the case of supplements containing calcium
and vitamin D), and possible hypercalciuria leading to kidney stone formation.
However, recent studies indicate that increased intake of calcium does not increase
risk of kidney stones. Moreover, restricting dietary calcium may increase urinary
excretion of oxalate which in turn increases risk of kidney stones.
For
certain individuals who cannot meet their calcium needs from foods, calcium supplements
are warranted. However as reviewed above, a number of factors influence the choice
of calcium preparation. Individuals who need calcium supplements should choose
one that contains a relatively high percentage of elemental calcium by weight,
disintegrates readily, provides a form of calcium that is bioavailable and inexpensive,
is manufactured by a reputable pharmaceutical company, and is free of toxicants.
In general, absorption of calcium is most efficient when the supplement is consumed
in doses of 200 mg or less. Intake of calcium supplements with vitamin D should
be limited because of the risk for vitamin D toxicity.
Absorbability
Calcium products are generally
absorbed easily in the body. Tablets and pills are not the best solution for an
added intake of calcium, as they vary in their ability to be fully digested. How
well a tablet dissolves can be determined by placing it in a small amount of warm
water for 30 minutes, stirring it occasionally. If it hasn’t dissolved within
this time it probably will not dissolve in the stomach.
Liquid
calcium supplements dissolve well because they are broken down before they enter
the stomach. There are some
"high tech" calcium supplements available that must be mixed in a liquid, than
drunk. These deliver nearly 100% of their available mineral solution as
they are in a nearly "pre-digested" state.
Calcium,
whether from the diet or supplements, is absorbed best by the body when it is
taken several times a day in amounts of 200 mg or less, but taking it all at once
is better than not taking it at all. Calcium carbonate is absorbed best when taken
with food. Calcium citrate can be taken any time.
Tolerance
While calcium supplements
generally are a satisfactory option for many people, certain preparations may
cause side effects, such as gas or constipation,
in some individuals. If simple measures such as increased fluids and fiber intake
do not solve the problem, another form of calcium should be tried. Also, it is
important to increase supplement intake gradually; take 200 mg a day for a week,
then add more calcium slowly.
Calcium
Interactions
It is
important to talk with a physician or pharmacist about possible interactions between
prescription or over-the-counter medications and calcium
supplements. For example, calcium supplements also may reduce the absorption of
the antibiotic tetracycline. Calcium also interferes with iron absorption, so
a calcium supplement should not be taken at the same time as an iron supplement.
The exception to this is when the iron supplement is taken with vitamin C or calcium
citrate. Any medication to be taken on an empty stomach should not be taken with
calcium supplements.
Combination
Products
Calcium supplements
are available in a dazzling array of combinations with vitamins and other minerals.
While vitamin D is necessary for the absorption of calcium, it is not necessary
that it be in the calcium supplement. Minerals such as magnesium and phosphorus
also are important, but usually are obtained through food or multivitamins. Most
experts recommend that nutrients come from a balanced diet, with multivitamins
used to supplement dietary deficiencies.
Most
published studies show that low calcium intake is associated with low bone mass,
rapid bone loss and high fracture rates. Adequate calcium intake will help ensure
that calcium deficiency is not contributing to a weakening of the skeleton.
Back to Calcium
Information
Return to the main
Calcium page
Back to Nutritional
page.
"These
statements have not been evaluated by the FDA.
This product is not intended
to diagnose, cure, prevent or treat any diseases."
The above is a Government ORDERED statement.
It is NOT based
in either reality or sanity.
Just like our Government. In
a landmark decision on Friday, Jan. 15, 1999, the US Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia ruled that the health claim rules
imposed by the FDA
unconstitutional and in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
The court instructed the FDA to define "significant scientific agreement"
for health claims on dietary supplement labels, and instructed the FDA to allow
the use of disclaimers on labels rather than to suppress these claims outright.
The court further held that four FDA Final rules (prohibiting certain nutrient
disease relationship claims) invalid under the first Amendment to the Constitution.